Meller spent 20 years in prison for a murder he didn’t commit, after police fabricated a case against him through the notorious “Operation Stickman” undercover task force.
CHICAGO — Attorneys for Daniel Meller have filed a federal lawsuit on his behalf against the City of Chicago, eight officers of the Chicago Police Department, Cook County, and two Assistant State’s Attorneys, alleging that they knowingly framed Meller for a 1998 a murder he had nothing to do with. Meller spent more than twenty years in prison, until his sentence was vacated by the court this past March.
No witnesses or forensic evidence ever connected Meller to the crime. According to the lawsuit filed on November 18, his conviction came about because CPD officers knowingly manufactured evidence against him in connection with a notorious undercover task force called “Operation Stickman,” which used an informant within the Latin Saints street gang to close unsolved crimes. Meller was exonerated after two other men, Francisco Romero and Michael Samanta, uncovered evidence that they been similarly framed through Operation Stickman.
“The CPD had a grant to fund this program, Operation Stickman, in which a known criminal was supposed to rat out his fellow gang members,” explains attorney Brian Morris of the civil rights law firm of Loevy + Loevy. “But the funding was contingent on securing convictions, and—after months with no results—the pressure was on to justify the Operation. So, these officers turned the screws, pressuring the informant to frame innocent men like Meller in order to close cases.”
In the summer of 1998, a man named Amparo Diaz was fatally shot in a drive-by shooting in the Back of the Yards neighborhood on Chicago’s Southwest Side. Remarkably, Detectives recovered the murder weapon from a man who identified the shooter. But, for reasons known only to the officers, they failed to follow-up on this critical lead, and the case went cold.
According to the lawsuit, it was not until three years later, in 2001, that—under pressure to produce results from “Operation Stickman”—the defendant officers fed their notoriously unreliable informant facts about at least six unsolved murders, including that of Amparo Diaz, and forced him to help them manufacture evidence to secure convictions. The informant—who was given incentives to cooperate, and who was allegedly beaten by his handlers when he didn’t—gave them Daniel Meller as the fall guy for Diaz’s murder.
Even so, it took another two years for the officers to even interview Meller. When they did, Meller honestly and steadfastly insisted upon his innocence, but the officers ignored both his denials and his requests for an attorney. The lawsuit alleges that after many hours of interrogation—in which they tortured Meller physically and psychologically—the officers succeeded in forcing him to give a “confession.” Tellingly, this confession contained no corroborating facts beyond those that had been fed to him by his interrogators.
As a result, Meller was convicted of the murder in 2005. He was sentenced to 35 years in prison.
“This program should have been called Operation Strawman,” says attorney Jennifer Blagg. “Because these officers cared nothing about finding the real murderer of Amparo Diaz. All they cared about was protecting their cash-cow operation. So when their informant proved to be useless, they turned the screws. They used pressure, threats, and incentives to get the informant to make stuff up in order to frame innocent men like Daniel Meller, who paid the price for defendants’ corruption”
Meller never stopped protesting his innocence or fighting to secure his freedom. But the corruption only came to light nearly 20 years later, when the Romero and Samanta cases exposed the rampant misconduct of Operation Stickman in 2024. Two years later, in March of 2026, the Court vacated Meller’s conviction as well, after he had spent more than two decades behind bars.
The complaint filed yesterday names as defendants: Chicago police officers John Ball, Robert Bartik, William Buglio, Thomas Cepeda, Clif Gehrke, William Moser, William Svilar, and other unknown law enforcement officers; Assistant Cook County State’s Attorneys Karen Armbrust and Mary Beth Fahey; and both Cook County and the City of Chicago.
“This misconduct—that caused Meller’s wrongful conviction—is part of a much larger pattern and practice of corruption and a culture of misconduct within the Chicago Police Department, and thus, the City of Chicago,” the complaint contends.
Meller is represented by Jon Loevy, Steve Art, Anand Swaminathan, Brian Morris, and Jordan Poole of Loevy + Loevy, and Jennifer Blagg and Eric Bisby of Blagg Law.
###
To read the complaint in this case, click here.